Incommon Renewing Error
Workaround:

1. Renew using existing CSR
   1. Using the existing CSR from your previous certificate that you want to renew. Add new certificate request and using the existing CSR and forcing SCM to use a new certificate profile.
   2. Download certificate to that machine that has that private key.
2. Create a new Certificate with out renewing.
   1. Create a new CSR from the machine you want to install the certificate on.
   2. Upload the CSR to SCM and request new certificate.
   3. Download and install

These work arounds can also be done by API method as well.